The Semiotics of Robin Ventura

When the White Sox stunned the baseball world by hiring Robin Ventura as their next manager (it’s not difficult to stun the baseball world), an interesting theme emerged:

“[Ventura is] honest, down to Earth and smart.” — Jon Heyman, Sports Illustrated

“His baseball knowledge and expertise, his professionalism, his familiarity with the White Sox and Chicago and his outstanding character make him absolutely the right person to lead our clubhouse and this organization into the seasons ahead.” — White Sox GM Ken Williams

“Ventura is a bright guy, by all accounts” — Morris Daily Herald

“Ventura’s smart and will be all class,” — David A. Haugh, Chicago Tribune

“Ventura is a nice, smart guy who may be a good manager, eventually.” — Dan Bernstein, CBSChicago

“He’s a smart person that I believe is the man we need for this position at this particular time.” — Williams

“He’s smart and has good people skills.” — Chris Jaffe, Hardball Times

“Robin’s really smart.” — Former White Sox manager Gene Lamont

You get the idea.

Hey, what are people saying about the Marlins’ hiring of Ozzie Guillen?

Fiery and energetic” — Joe Frisaro,

“Guillen spent his first 13 major league seasons as a fiery shortstop with the Sox” — Juan C. Rodriguez, Chicago Tribune

“Hurricane Ozzie” — Marlins Owner/Ringwraith Jeffrey Loria

“Both current and former players for the Marlins described Guillen as outspoken and feisty.” — Clark Spencer, Miami Herald

“It’s hard to think of fiery Ozzie Guillen ever lacking in the passion department.” — Chris Tomasson, FoxSports Florida

“Ozzie Guillen introduced by Marlins, praised for great passion” — Brian McIntyre, SB Nation


Look, I’m not saying that Robin Ventura isn’t smart. And I’m certainly not saying that Ozzie Guillen isn’t fiery and passionate. But…um…maybe there’s a little something else going into these descriptions beyond the managers’ respective personalities? Just maybe?

Do we have access to Ventura’s IQ or SAT scores? Or is it possible that Ventura is “smart” the same way that David Eckstein is “gritty,” and the same way that B.J. Upton is “toolsy”? Let’s just maybe choose our words a little more carefully out there, OK?


Leave a comment

Filed under Sports Has AIDS, The Dilemma

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s